Viewing Single Post From: Voting Thread

Viewing Single Post From: Voting Thread
Yzarc	Sep 13 2007, 10:43 AM
Coxian Posts: 3,432 Group: Veteran Member #308 Joined: July 8, 2005	Just read Mekkah v Inui. A few notes: @Mekkah: Why is it better for Lugh to attack rather than heal and for Clarine/Saul to heal rather than attack? You made this point several times in your final post but didn't explain it. Inui didn't attack it, however, so it basically isn't a negative. I'm just curious, really. @Inui: Faggot, use your own arguments, don't steal from Reikken. @Mekkah: Inui pointed out one fact that you seemed to have gotten wrong, but I'm not sure about since I haven't played the game. You said Wyverns need 36 attack to kill Ellen, but Inui said they cap at 30, while you said they could reach 36. I'm a little confused. @Inui: You didn't do hardly ANYTHING to prove that Ellen > Saul. You said her avoid was higher, but Mekkah countered that adequately enough. The only thing you did here was continuously repeat "Ellen > Saul" without really backing it up. Not nearly as much as Mekkah did to prove that Saul > Ellen. Basically, if that was a Saul v Ellen debate, Mekkah would have EASILY won. Of course, it wasn't, so this is just a point that goes in his direction. This debate was really boring over all. No comedy, just stats and disagreements on many issues. Inui says Marcus should be used way more early on than Mekkah agrees with. Haven't played the game, so I'm not gonna say which of you is more right here. I don't know if Marcus should be used more often when he's good. However, Mekkah basically proved that Marcus caps out at chapter 8 and Inui completely agreed. That seems to be a very small portion of the game. CATS By the last post, it sounded like he was almost admitting that Marcus wins all the ranks except Exp. I disagree. He was saying that Saul helps Exp throughout the game while Marcus wins a few more ranks than that in the few chapters he's in. Mekkah did make it a significant point that Marcus' wins, while important for the short time that they are there, are not as significant as Saul's throughout the game. If you haven't guessed, I'm voting Mekkah. EDIT: Oh, and could someone vote for CATS v Yzarc?


Voting Thread · Debate Challenges