Viewing Single Post From: Tier List Discussion

Viewing Single Post From: Tier List Discussion
Mekkah	Apr 4 2009, 10:38 AM
Posts: 667 Group: FEFFer Member #1,400 Joined: July 24, 2007	SF has a tier list that's discussed with much more detail than here but... Lena is too high. Her stats suck monkey balls, and staves aren't really much special in a game where generic replacements and reclass units can heal as well. All she has is Warp staff, and after promo nearly everyone can do that, and before that warping is generally undesirable. Xane should be pretty much above anyone except Zagaro and Wolf, since he's basically a carbon copy of anything you want. Linda being anything but Bottom is ridiculous. Just look at her durability. Hell, what is Marth doing below there? Beck and Jake should be next to each other. Maria sucks about as much as Linda, just moreso due to no Aura. Quote: Notes: Only Gaiden character considered is Nagi because she is recruitable without sucking at the game. Just kill off people you're not using. It means you can be more careless with them, and you get free Iron weapons from generic replacements, plus the gaiden units make generally good fillers or even perm team members (Athena, Horace, Etzel). Quote: Oguma is way too nerfed to still be a contender for best character. You should look at this game on its own instead of comparing them to their FE3 incarnations. It has no practical value. It's like moving down FE6 Marcus below FE6 Bartre simply because he went a long way down from FE7 Marcus. Quote: Maria even gets better than him really quickly. She's better than ??/10 Wendell at 20/1, and every healer is ridiculously easy to level up, and Maria can promote after only a few characters... She's having trouble healing anything since she gets one-rounded by everything on the map forever. And Wendell has much more than a 10 level lead on her, especially when you consider that Maria has to cut out awesome people for promotion time just to become him. And Wendell has Excalibur. I question Cain and Abel in the same tier as Wolf and Zagaro as well. Invincibility >>>>> movement lead. Quote: It's working so far, since I haven't seen you prove my point wrong. As long as neither of us doesn't prove our point to be correct, anything's fair game. That's only a good thing in official biased debates, but it's annoying if you keep playing that card in topics that are actually supposed to go somewhere without having to explain to you why exactly Guy is a better unit than Wil in FE7. Quote: Wolf and Zagaro don't have good offense at all, which Oguma does have, while he's actually fairly durable himself thanks to high spd (so he basically never gets doubled) and pretty damn massive hp, so I'd argue Oguma's offense lead > their durability lead. You didn't even look at Wolf/Zagaro's durability compared to Oguma's. I recommend you do so, as there is much much much much more to it than "not getting doubled" and "pretty damn massive hp". Especially mid and lategame, their leads are so massive, they could take 3 hits from every melee enemy on the map and still have more than 3/4 of their hp left. As for Ogma's offense, he has trouble doubling. I think that about sums up how much better his offense is than Wolf and Zagaro.


Tier List Discussion · Fire Emblem 9-11