William Rhodes

Oct 19 2005, 06:17 PM

admin

Oct 18 2005, 06:23 PM

William Rhodes

Oct 16 2005, 06:15 PM

Bakedalasker

Do you think the role of the Forum Moderating Team is to try (as best they can) to ensure accuracy, fairness and balence in the postings?

Regards

William Rhodes

I would strongly recommend you get your own house in order before making any comments on how this forum is run.

Admin

Interesting posts. I make no comment about how ths site is run or have given any view.

Bakedalasker is a Moderator and has expressed support for Whisperwolf in his postings which seems strange when he then will not then be drawn on the subject of whether he feels Whisperwolf's posts are accurate.

Surely when people read the posts they can make thier own mind up.

I have expressed doubt over the accuracy of the post by Whisperwolf (I have good reason) - however because I expressed my view about Whisperwolf's position it does not mean that I am calling into question other people that have posted. I have never posted a note expressing doubt over any other member's contribution.

We should all have an open mind until we know all (or the majority of) the facts about a particular position.

I guess what frustrates me about the Whisperwolf situation is the "blind" acceptance that a certian set of circumstances are true - when it agrees with a moderator's view of an organisation.

It just so happens in this instance I was lucky enough to be able to identify the Collector(s) and the person who made the call to us - literally within 30 minutes of the call being handled.

I would have been very happy for you to review the "tape" of the call made and report to us all - I think you would have been fair and accurate in your reporting.

Sadly I suspect we will hear no more.

William Rhodes